Will environmentalists miss George Bush?

September 13th, 2008

Posted by: admin

No doubt, environmentalists are counting down the days until President Bush leaves office. However, is this parting bittersweet? Consider the following figure on the number of Americans that claim to belong to an environmental organization.

According to this dataset, the number of American’s that belong to an environmental organization correlates with presidential party affiliation; claimed membership is approximately 50% greater during a Republican presidency.

I created the figure by harvesting polling data from six different polls between 1978 and 2005. All six polls roughly ask the same question: do you belong to an environmental organization? The blue points represent the percentage of respondents answering in the affirmative. The percentage is found on the left axis. I was curious how these percentages translated into actual numbers of American citizens. To do this, I multiplied the percentage of affirmative respondents by the US Census’ estimate for each year, which is illustrated by the red points. The number of Americans is found on the right axis.

I am fully aware of the challenges of comparing the results of different surveys. This figure is a back of the envelope calculation to help triangulate relevant trends for my research. While the results are not definitive they certainly are suggestive.

For those interested, the exact polling questions are below:

1978: Do you belong to any national environment organizations such as the Sierra Club, Friends of the Earth, the National Audubon Society or others like these? (Survey by Resources for the Future)

1982: Do you belong to any of the following types of community organizations?…Environmental groups. (Survey by Continental Group)

1990: Please look carefully at the following list of voluntary organizations and activities and say which, if any, do you belong to?…Conservation, the environment, ecology (Gallup Organization)

1996: We would like to know something about the groups or organizations to which you currently belong. Here is a list of various kinds of organizations. For each type, please tell me whether you belong to any club or organization that fits into that category. Just call off the number of each type you belong to… environmental clubs or organizations (Post-Modernity Project at the University of Virginia)

2000: There are many different kinds of environmental organizations, including large national and international organizations like the Sierra Club and Greenpeace, as well as smaller, local organizations. Do you, yourself, belong to any large national or international environmental organizations? (Gallup organization)

2005: There are many different kinds of environmental organizations, including large national and international organizations like the Sierra Club and Greenpeace, as well as smaller, local organizations. Do you, yourself, belong to any large national or international environmental organizations? (Gallup organization)

5 Responses to “Will environmentalists miss George Bush?”

    1
  1. Sylvain Says:

    Their could be a counter-justification for this phenomenon. Maybe more people join environmentalist groups when republican are in power because they feel less secure about it than when democrats are in power.

  2. 2
  3. Sylvain Says:

    Of course, some of these organization might miss Bush money wise.

  4. 3
  5. stan Says:

    The homeless disappeared from the news media from Jan 1993 – Jan 2001. Less than two weeks after W took office, the NY Times ran a big story on the homeless. I suspect a similar lull in environmental disaster stories during the same time period.

  6. 4
  7. More Environmentalists During Republican Administrations | Skeptics Global Warming Says:

    [...] Read More: sciencepolicy.colorado.edu Tags: America, colorado, democrats, Environmentalists, Science Related Posts [...]

  8. 5
  9. Websites tagged "dataset" on Postsaver Says:

    [...] saved by leip2008-11-17 – Greek Hackers attack CERN – What if? saved by johncollins2008-11-16 – Will environmentalists miss George Bush? saved by OBursts2008-10-31 – Office Visitor saved by lsdr2008-10-31 – Thesis in Six Weeks saved by [...]